Is Walmart Plus or Amazon Prime the best service for you?

New contender

Walmart+



Trusted by many

Amazon Prime


Amazon Prime official logo

Walmart+ may be less than two years old, but it’s proving to be one of the best Amazon Prime competitors we’ve seen. Walmart has tons of locations spread across the country, making it a great way for people all over to take advantage of its benefits.

$98/year at Walmart

Pros

  • More affordable than Prime
  • Has in-store benefit options
  • Brings grocery service to more users

While it may cost about $40 more to sign up for Amazon’s Prime service, right now you actually get more for your money when using it. Between the additional streaming content, access to more products, and other perks, Prime may be the best option for you.

$139/year at Amazon

Pros

  • More product availability
  • Better third-party seller ecosystem
  • More Prime member exclusive benefits

Cons

  • More expensive than Walmart’s offering

Walmart+ launched in September 2020 as a direct competitor to Amazon Prime. While Walmart wants to be the online shopping powerhouse that Amazon already is, you can’t be on the same level without the same level of benefits for members. But just how similar are the two services? Where does Walmart excel and what can Amazon still bring to the table that Walmart can’t? With all of this in mind, we’ve compared Walmart+ and Amazon Prime side-by-side right here so you can see exactly which one is right for you.

Walmart+ vs. Amazon Prime: Comparing costs

All other things being equal, the cost will most likely be the largest factor that determines whether someone might go with one service or the other. It’s the most basic comparison we need to make.

Walmart+ costs $98 a year. You can also get it by paying $12.95 a month if you don’t want to invest in a full year of the service. When you first sign up, you can try it out and all of its benefits for free for 30 days.

Amazon Prime costs $139 a year or $14.99 a month. That makes Walmart+ much cheaper for the average person, but Prime does have a couple of ways to get the price discounted. Students, for example, can get a free six-month trial of Prime and then pay just $59 for the service after that. People on government assistance are eligible for a discount, too. Like Walmart+, Prime also comes with a 30-day free trial.

Walmart+ vs. Amazon Prime: Delivery benefits

Prime Day Boxes

Source: Getty Images Europe

Amazon Prime has a myriad of benefits going for it now, but originally the main draw was the novel concept of free two-day shipping on everything Amazon has to offer. That’s still one of the best reasons to get a service like this because it means doing away with shipping thresholds, hidden fees, and that sort of thing. Delivery is a lot more complicated now, so how do the two services compare?

Amazon Prime obviously has free two-day shipping, but it also has free one-day delivery on millions of items. Certain areas around the country can also get free same-day delivery or even free two-hour delivery through Prime Now. Other shipping benefits include free release-date delivery on certain pre-ordered items and free no-rush shipping where Amazon rewards you (usually in the form of Amazon credit) for picking a slower shipping speed if you’re not in a hurry.

Amazon Prime also offers grocery service, but it may be more limited based on where you live.

The primary Walmart+ benefit will be its Unlimited Free Delivery. Similar to Prime, this includes free two-day shipping and a free same-day delivery service. However, Prime does not require a minimum order amount and Walmart+ does have a $35 threshold on grocery items. The free delivery will apply to everything Walmart sells in its stores, which is more than 160,000 items. That also includes groceries, which could be a huge incentive for you if you live near a Walmart and desire grocery delivery.

Amazon Prime does offer a grocery service but it may be more limited based on where you live. Around 2,000 cities have access to two-hour grocery delivery from Amazon Fresh and Whole Foods Market, and you can get free delivery from Amazon Pantry if you spend over $35.

Walmart+ vs. Amazon Prime: In-store benefits

Walmart Storefront

Source: Walmart

This is a tough one for Amazon because Amazon doesn’t have a lot of stores to be in. Given how common Walmart stores are, it makes sense that Walmart would want to leverage this advantage.

One of the Walmart+ benefits here is its Mobile scan & go feature. This is a service that lets you use the Walmart app on your phone to scan items as you pick them up and pay using Walmart Pay online, basically streamlining the in-store experience. The app makes going to the store fast, easy, and touch-free.

You can also use your Walmart+ subscription to save on gas. Walmart has nearly 2,000 fuel stations through Walmart, Murphy USA, and Murphy Express stations. You can save five cents per gallon at any of these locations, as well as access member prices at Sam’s Club fuel centers.

With Amazon Prime, you can save money at Whole Foods Market, which Amazon owns. This grocery store can give you 5% back if you’re a Prime member and use your Amazon Prime Rewards Visa card. They also regularly have exclusive savings for Prime members on groceries and two-hour delivery in some places.

Amazon also has shops like the Amazon 4-star shops and Amazon Books stores. You can expect to pay the same prices in-store that you’d pay online in locations like these as long as you’re a Prime member.

Walmart+ vs. Amazon Prime: All the entertainment options

Prime Video

Source: Android Central

If Walmart has the advantage of leveraging its in-store benefits, then Amazon’s advantage comes from its extensive content library and streaming options. In fact, outside of potential savings on in-store entertainment, Walmart+ has no real way to save in the entertainment realm. However, there have been rumors that Walmart is looking to develop its own entertainment service under the Walmart+ umbrella. Right now, all we have is Camp by Walmart, which is a free service for anyone with the Walmart app that dips its toes into digital entertainment.

With Amazon Prime, you get full access to Prime Video. This includes unlimited streaming of movies and TV shows, originals developed by Amazon like The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, and easy access to rent or own movies or TV shows that aren’t automatically free on Prime. You can even download some for offline viewing. You can add to this service with Amazon Channels, which gives you easy access to premium channels like HBO and Showtime for just $5 to $15 extra a month.

Walmart+ has no real way to save in the entertainment realm.

You can also stream music through Amazon Prime Music or Amazon Music Unlimited, the latter of which gives you access to even more songs. If you’re into video games, Prime Gaming gives you one free channel subscription (worth $4.99) on Twitch.tv, another Amazon-owned property, free games every month, and exclusive in-game content released regularly for all your favorite games.

Amazon also has Prime Reading and Amazon First Reads, two ways to save on books. With Prime Reading, Prime members can borrow and read thousands of books, magazines, and such for free. Read them anywhere and even get some with Audible narration so you can switch between reading and listening. First Reads lets you pick from a selection of books every month and get one of them free to read. New Prime subscribers are also invited to start their 30-day free trial for Audible, Amazon’s audiobook service, with two free credits. Each credit can be used to purchase a Premium title from a collection of more than 500,000 audiobook titles.

Walmart+ vs. Amazon Prime: Which one is right for you?

Amazon Prime has been around for 17 years, meaning it’s no surprise that Prime is going to have a few more tools on its belt than the newer Walmart+ service. However, there are some advantages to being one of the largest brick-and-mortar retailers ever, and Walmart is definitely going to use that to its advantage. Walmart+ is already off to a great start with the benefits it does offer, and you can expect to see those benefits rapidly increase as time goes on. That’ll be especially true the more successful the service is at first.

Of course, as you can see, Amazon Prime has a lot of services Walmart just can’t compete with. This is especially true in the world of entertainment. The video and music streaming plus reading benefits of Prime are second to none. If those things really matter to you, then the extra cost for Prime might be worth the investment. However, if you’re just looking for a way to get your groceries delivered at in-store prices, Walmart+ is most likely going to be the service of choice. That’s totally up to you and based on where you live since Prime’s grocery delivery from Whole Foods Market does include in-store pricing and 10% off all sale items for Prime members.

Big box benefits


Walmart Plus

Walmart+

Spend less now

Walmart+ allows subscribers to order groceries as often as they want for free. You’ll also have early access to a variety of special promotions and events, Black Friday deals, and product releases.

Prime delivery


Amazon Prime official logo

Amazon Prime

Get all the perks

Amazon Prime members enjoy free and quick delivery on a variety of items, as well as free two-hour grocery deliveries and access to the extensive Prime Video streaming library.

We may earn a commission for purchases using our links. Learn more.

Source link